How to Make Legendary & Mythical Ice Cream in Grow a Garden

Looking for a step-by-step guide on how to make legendary and mythical ice cream in Grow a Garden? This cooking update introduces several new ice cream recipes that are essential for completing quests and earning exclusive rewards from the NPC Chris P. Here’s how to create each ice cream variant, what ingredients you need, and the best way to use them for maximum reward.

What Is Ice Cream in Grow a Garden?

Ice cream is a new quest item introduced during the Grow a Garden cooking update. There are currently two legendary ice cream recipes and one mythical ice cream recipe, each requiring a different combination of fruits. Ice cream cannot be sold for extra profit or used to boost crops—it is solely intended for feeding the pig chef NPC, Chris P, in the center of the map.

Legendary Ice Cream Recipes

There are two legendary ice cream variants you can make:

• Legendary Ice Cream Recipe 1:
  1x Pineapple + 1x Corn

• Legendary Ice Cream Recipe 2:
  1x Banana + 1x Sugar Apple

Both legendary variants follow the same process and cooking time. Once completed, they are used exclusively for fulfilling Chris P’s craving quests.

How to Make Mythical Ice Cream

Mythical ice cream is a rarer variant and requires a slightly different recipe:

• Mythical Ice Cream Recipe:
  2x Banana

Mythical ice cream is not available in prismatic form and, like the legendary variants, is designed for quest turn-ins only.

Step-by-Step Guide: Making Ice Cream in Grow a Garden

1. Prepare Your Ingredients:
   Gather the specific fruits required for your chosen ice cream recipe (see above).

2. Go to the Cauldron:
   Head to the cauldron near Chris P at the center of the map.

3. Insert Ingredients:
   Place the required fruits into the cauldron. Only the correct combinations listed above will create legendary or mythical ice cream.

4. Start Cooking:
   Press the “Cook” button. The cooking process takes exactly 5 minutes and 48 seconds for all ice cream variants.

5. Collect Your Ice Cream:
   Once the timer ends, collect the ice cream from the cauldron.

6. Check Chris P’s Craving:
   Before giving ice cream to Chris P, look at the speech bubble above his head to see what food he’s currently craving. Only deliver ice cream when he requests it for the best reward chance.

How to Use Ice Cream and Get Better Rewards

After making ice cream, your only use for it is to feed Chris P during his specific ice cream craving. Giving Chris P the food he craves is the best way to increase your chances of receiving rare rewards, such as Gourmet Egg, Gourmet Seed Pack, or even unique cosmetic items. Ice cream itself provides no bonus for plants, farming yield, or pet benefits—it is a pure quest item.

Tips:

• Always check Chris P’s craving before delivering food.

• Use the right recipe for the rarity of ice cream Chris P wants.

• Legendary and mythical ice cream do not give additional benefits outside of quest rewards.

Final Thoughts

Making legendary and mythical ice cream in Grow a Garden is simple once you know the recipes: Pineapple and Corn, Banana and Sugar Apple for legendary, and two Bananas for mythical. Always prepare your ingredients, follow the correct cooking process, and pay attention to Chris P’s cravings for the best rewards. Ice cream is purely for quest use, so time your cooking and deliveries to maximize your event progress and quest prizes.